How to use 35% better match rates to cut cost-to-collect

Written by: Stuart Murgatroyd

28 November, 2025

Cost-to-collect is eating into margins across the collections industry.  Yet when data match rates jump up 35%, everything downstream changes. Forecasts stop being guesswork. Liquidation models actually hold up. And capital quits sitting in accounts where no one picks up the phone.

But some collections operations treat data quality as a nice-to-have. Instead, they invest in better dialling tech, smarter segmentation, and even AI-powered decisioning, then feed it contact information that’s six months out of date.

The result? Low contact rates. Inflated cost-per-dollar-collected. Models that collapse on contact with real portfolios.

Meanwhile, pressure’s stacking up. Margins are razor-thin. Vulnerable customer protections are tightening. Regulators want defensible practices. And capital allocators are asking harder questions about recovery assumptions.

Today, we look at how better match rates are reshaping the economics of collections, turning data precision into measurable cost control and stronger recovery outcomes.

The new economics of right-party contact

Right-party contact has always been seen as an operational KPI shaped by dialler logic, call strategy, and resource planning. But it’s far more than that. It influences:

  • how portfolios are valued
  • how recoveries are forecast
  • and how capital is deployed.

 

When verified match rates increase, the impact runs through every layer of the business. Finance teams gain confidence in the accuracy of their models. Contingency buffers reduce. Capital moves faster between portfolios. And contact performance improves as a result of cleaner, more reliable data.

There’s also a diagnostic side to this. Differences in match performance between portfolios reveal issues that management dashboards rarely show. They highlight inconsistencies in supplier quality, governance, and data strategy. When accuracy moves by more than a few points between portfolios, the cause is usually data control, not customer behaviour.

Collections leaders are beginning to focus on that point. The focus now is on understanding where data delivers value and where it starts to cost more than it returns. That change turns match precision into a matter of financial accountability.

In more advanced operations, this mindset is already embedded. Portfolio pricing includes a data quality coefficient. Dashboards track the gap between verified and assumed contacts. And high-performing teams link data confidence directly to portfolio yield, giving cost-to-collect a new level of financial transparency.

 

How data accuracy drives cost-to-collect efficiency

When cost-to-collect increases, it’s rarely because processes fail. The real issue is usually the bad data driving them. Inaccurate or incomplete records lead to wasted contact attempts, uneven agent performance, and unreliable yield forecasts. Yet many organisations still treat this purely as an operational issue.

Every attempt to reach the wrong customer carries a cost. It eats up dialler time, inflates workforce effort, and undermines confidence in portfolio performance. That’s why the most advanced collections teams now treat data accuracy as part of their financial governance framework.

FinTrace was built around that principle. It brings together compliant, high-frequency data sources – validated contact details, employment information, and income insights – to give collections teams a verified view of customer reachability. The data refreshes daily, so teams always work with the most accurate version of each record.

Clients using FinTrace typically see a 35% improvement in match rates compared to bureau-only data. That uplift translates directly into cost efficiency:

Throughput efficiency: Higher verified contacts make every agent minute more productive, without increasing headcount.

Forecast efficiency: Consistent reachability stabilises recovery projections and reduces performance variance.

Acquisition efficiency: Verified data strengthens portfolio valuation, improving bid accuracy and post-purchase yield.

Here’s an example of this process in action:

Case study: Coeo UK

Coeo’s digital-first strategy was already delivering strong engagement, but the team saw untapped potential in their portfolio performance. They needed a data solution that could keep up with automated processes and digital journeys.

Data On Demand implemented FinTrace via API, providing enhanced contact channel data and real-time customer insights. The integration replaced periodic updates with live data feeds, allowing Coeo to adjust its strategies daily.

“The API integration transformed our approach to data,” says Ben Calvert, Commercial Director at Coeo UK. “Instead of periodic updates, we’re now working with real-time information. This means our strategies are always based on the latest customer data, which is crucial for digital engagement.”

The impact was immediate. Portfolio match rates increased, contact success rates improved, and digital engagement strengthened. Enhanced data quality supported more accurate propensity scoring, improved operational efficiency, and delivered better customer outcomes across both debt purchase and contingent portfolios.

“The reliability of the data has been exceptional,” Ben adds. “When you’re managing large debt portfolios across multiple sectors, the quality of your data directly impacts your ability to achieve positive outcomes.”

FinTrace turns accuracy into control. It helps leaders run leaner, more predictable operations and gives them confidence that every attempt, every contact, and every forecast is based on verified data.

How data accuracy strengthens financial control in collections

Many organisations still view cost-to-collect as a measure of efficiency. The most advanced leaders now see it differently. It’s a measure of control: financial, operational, and reputational. It shows how well a business can predict, manage, and evidence performance when it’s under scrutiny.

FinTrace supports that level of control. Its verified contact, employment, and income data provides a single, trusted source for finance, risk, and operations teams. By removing uncertainty around reachability, it strengthens the link between front-line activity and board-level accountability.

This level of accuracy drives improvement far beyond performance metrics:

  1. Financial control: Reliable match data stabilises forecasts, reduces volatility in recoveries, and helps lower the capital buffers held against underperformance.
  2. Risk assurance: Up-to-date records demonstrate compliant customer engagement and create defensible audit trails, essential for Consumer Duty and FCA oversight.
  3. Operational governance: Verified data supports consistent decisions across teams and suppliers, reducing the risk of divergence between systems and improving overall data management.

 

When accuracy is embedded into financial governance, cost-to-collect becomes a live indicator of how effectively data translates into value. It gives leaders tangible proof that performance is measurable, compliant, and financially sound.

 

From financial control to performance infrastructure

For high-performing collections teams, precision is a must-have. The ability to measure, predict, and evidence every stage of recovery depends on how well data supports the commercial model behind it. FinTrace was built to make that level of precision possible.

The platform connects data on over 35 million UK individuals and 26 million households, updating more than 3 million records each month across email, phone, and postal channels. That scale provides reach and visibility. It gives leaders the confidence to model recoveries accurately, validate supplier performance, and track engagement outcomes across entire portfolios.

FinTrace adds value throughout the collections process:

Portfolio targeting and segmentation

FinTrace helps identify where uncontactable accounts cluster across portfolios or creditors. This insight improves portfolio acquisition, risk-weighting, and pricing accuracy (vital for debt purchasers and agencies managing mixed books).

Digital engagement at scale

With verified digital identifiers including 44 million email addresses and 31 million mobile numbers, FinTrace supports the shift to lower-cost, higher-yield digital channels. Teams can prioritise email and SMS before outbound calls, increasing right-party contact rates while reducing cost-to-contact.

Compliance and governance

Every data point in FinTrace comes from permissioned, GDPR-compliant sources, giving firms defensible evidence of data provenance. This strengthens audit trails and meets FCA expectations for accurate, fair, and traceable customer communication.

Operational efficiency and refresh cycles

FinTrace’s real-time APIs update customer records as soon as new information becomes available. This prevents database drift, reduces repeat traces, and keeps engagement strategies aligned with current customer circumstances.

For senior collections leaders, this approach changes the economics of portfolio management. When data quality is stable at the source, accuracy becomes a financial advantage that drives higher recovery predictability, lower operational waste, and greater confidence in every forecast.

FinTrace gives collections teams the structure to run recovery as a data-led, financially governed discipline that’s accurate, accountable, and built on evidence.

 

Proving ROI in collections through better data accuracy

For leaders focused on reducing cost-to-collect, improving contact rates is no longer enough. The advantage now lies in being able to prove, with data, that every operational pound spent delivers a measurable financial return.

That’s exactly what FinTrace enables. It’s verified, continuously refreshed data gives collections teams a stable foundation for engagement, performance forecasting, and compliance assurance. More importantly, it provides the evidence base needed to justify investment, demonstrate control, and show regulators and stakeholders that performance is both predictable and fair.

The next step is to quantify that impact using your own portfolios. Data On Demand’s Proof of Value framework lets you test FinTrace against live records, measure uplift in verified contacts, and see the cost efficiency gains in real numbers… All before committing to full deployment.

You’ll see where better data creates value, how quickly it pays back, and how much hidden performance potential your current approach leaves untapped.

Book a Proof of Value concept today.

Discover what Data On Demand can do for your business

Learn about how our products could benefit you.
Get in touch and find out about our solutions for Marketing, Verification and Trace.